Instagram Just Raised the Stakes for Creators — But Is It Really as Useful as It Seems?
Instagram is shaking things up again. The platform has just introduced a new “Competitive Insights” feature within its Professional Dashboard, aiming to give creators and brands a fresh way to measure how they stack up against others. Sounds powerful, right? But here’s where it gets controversial — is this feature actually helpful, or just another shiny number trap?
According to digital marketing advisor Sarah Roizman, who first shared a glimpse of this update, the feature allows users with business or creator accounts to compare their performance against up to 10 competitors. You’ll see side-by-side data covering follower growth, posting frequency, and activity across different formats — including Reels, feed posts, and ads.
At first glance, this sounds like a social media marketer’s dream. But there’s a catch. The insights are fairly basic and binary — offering surface-level metrics like how often competitors post versus how fast their audience grows. Interestingly, you can even peek at individual post performance, even when like counts are hidden. That’s a nice touch — yet, you won’t get access to deeper analytics like engagement graphs or group comparisons across multiple competitors.
So, is this really a game-changer, or just another vanity metric dashboard? The answer depends on what you’re after. If your main goal is to track follower growth, it might seem useful. But if you’re focused on conversions, clicks, and meaningful engagement, this update might fall short. After all, follower numbers don’t always equal success — it’s the clicks and conversions that actually drive results.
Imagine this: two accounts each gain 1,000 new followers. One drives 500 website clicks; the other drives none. Which one is performing better? That’s the part Instagram’s new feature doesn’t quite reveal.
To truly understand your social media performance, it’s important to focus on three key areas:
- Awareness – Growth in followers, engagement, shares, saves, and views.
- Nurturing – Views, likes, replies, clicks, and saves that build relationships.
- Conversion – Clicks and measurable actions (like share-to-click ratios) that lead to real outcomes.
These stages often overlap, but together they paint a more complete picture of your digital strategy’s health. A simple comparison of posting volume vs. follower growth just doesn’t tell you much about what’s really working.
That said, this could be just the first step in something bigger. Maybe Instagram plans to add deeper data comparisons down the line — metrics that include engagement rates, reach, or even conversion tracking. But for now, this feature feels like something halfway between useful and decorative — a step forward, but not the full story.
So, what do you think? Is Instagram’s new Competitive Insights a helpful benchmarking tool, or just another way to fuel the social media numbers game? Would you use it to evaluate your strategy — or do you think it misses the point of what really drives success online? Let’s discuss in the comments — because this one’s bound to divide opinions.
)
